The momentum of light in media: the Abraham-Minkowski controversy
نویسنده
چکیده
The controversy arises due to Abraham's and Minkowski's calculations disagreeing as to whether the momentum carried by an electromagnetic field is increased or decreased by the presence of a refractive medium. This paper starts by providing an overview of the life of Abraham and Minkowski. The opinions on the controversy, and solutions for the controversy proposed by physicists over the past century are considered, and the arguments they put forward to support their position are examined. Finally, some of the experiments undertaken are discussed, along with whether they have shed light on the controversy. The paper concludes by considering proposed future work on the topic.
منابع مشابه
Radiation pressure on submerged mirrors: implications for the momentum of light in dielectric media.
Radiation pressure measurements on mirrors submerged in dielectric liquids have consistently shown an effective Minkowski momentum for the photons within the liquid. Using an exact theoretical calculation based on Maxwell's equations and the Lorentz law of force, we demonstrate that this result is a consequence of the fact that conventional mirrors impart, upon reflection, a 180 degrees phase s...
متن کاملRadiation pressure of light pulses and conservation of linear momentum in dispersive media.
We derive an expression for the Minkowski momentum under conditions of dispersive susceptibility and permeability, and compare it to the Abraham momentum in order to test the principle of conservation of linear momentum when matter is present. We investigate cases when an incident pulse interacts with a variety of structures, including thick substrates, resonant, free-standing, micron-sized mul...
متن کاملAbraham, Minkowski and “Hidden” Mechanical Momentum
In general, D = E + 4πP and H = B − 4πM, where P and M are the densities of electric and magnetic polarization, respectively, while Abraham (and Minkowski) considered only linear media, where D = E and B = μH. All media except vacuum have both and μ different from unity. However, most media have μ , and most discussion [2] of the Abraham and Minkowski momenta assume that μ = 1. In this idealize...
متن کاملElectromagnetic energy and momentum in moving media
The problem of the electromagnetic energy-momentum tensor is among the oldest and the most controversial in macroscopic electrodynamics. In the center of the issue is a dispute about the Minkowski and the Abraham tensors for moving media. An overview of the current situation is presented. After putting the discussion into a general Lagrange-Noether framework, the Minkowski tensor is recovered a...
متن کاملElectromagnetic energy-momentum tensors in media
It is pointed out that the previous energy-momentum tensors of Minkowski and Abraham for the electromagnetic field in continuous media are based on a covariant formulation which does not reflect a symmetry inherent to the system. Instead, taking into account the intrinsic invariance under Lorentz transformations involving the reduced speed of light in such a medium, a compact and fully consiste...
متن کامل